Characterization Motor

From BurnSim Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

A characterization motor is a small, reusable test motor fired only to measure a propellant. Each firing gives one burn rate at one chamber pressure. Several firings through different nozzle throats give the burn rate curve, the a and n that every BurnSim simulation of that propellant depends on (see Propellant Characterization).

The motor is not meant to be efficient. It is meant to make every firing easy to read and hard to misread.

A good configuration: one short BATES grain

The configuration used for the BurnSim author's own test firings is a 54 mm motor with a single BATES grain:

Part Choice Why
Grain One BATES grain, 1.825 in OD × 0.625 in core × 3 in long, ends uninhibited Uninhibited ends make the grain nearly neutral: a BATES grain's burning area stays almost constant when its length is about (3D + d)/2, which is 3.05 in here. Chamber pressure then holds nearly flat through the burn, so "the" pressure the rate belongs to is well defined.
Web (1.825 − 0.625)/2 = 0.600 in, known exactly The burn rate is web / burn time. A grain cast to measured dimensions gives a web you can trust to a few thousandths.
Port 0.625 in core against a 0.25-0.28 in throat A port-to-throat area ratio of 5 or more keeps the gas in the port slow, so erosive burning does not inflate the rate you are trying to measure. A long stack of grains would not.
Propellant mass About 0.4 lb Cheap to cast, quick to make, and small enough to fire often.
Nozzle A plain nozzle with interchangeable throats (0.248 and 0.28 in, for example) Each throat gives a different chamber pressure and therefore one more point on the curve. Measure each throat before and after the firing.
Case Heavy-wall aluminum (here 6061 schedule 80 pipe) with snap ring closures A characterization motor is fired at pressures chosen for the data, not for performance, and it is fired over and over. Build it with a wide margin over the highest pressure you plan, and run the case strength check on it.
Pressure tap Through the forward bulkhead, grease-filled to the transducer Head-end pressure, kept away from the hot gas.
Igniter At the head end, its leads out through the nozzle A small igniter lights the grain without adding much gas of its own, so the start of the pressure rise belongs to the propellant.

Nothing about this is specific to 54 mm. Any short single grain with uninhibited ends, a modest port-to-throat ratio and an oversized case works the same way. A 38 mm version needs less propellant, and a larger one gives a longer burn that is easier to time.

Getting the most out of each firing

  • Log fast. 1-2 kHz resolves the ignition rise and the tail-off. 100 Hz is enough for the burn rate but blurs the first few tens of milliseconds.
  • Record a fire marker, a spare data channel across the igniter leads, so t=0 is the moment the firing circuit closed. See Data Acquisition.
  • Weigh the grain before the firing, and measure the throat before and after. A throat that grew during the burn is a different motor at the end than at the start.
  • Import the whole trace from before ignition to after burnout. BurnSim finds the burn itself (see Import the whole trace).
  • Add every firing to the burn rate data set with Add to Burn Rate Data... on the Test Data tab. Keep the ones you doubt and untick them, rather than deleting them.
  • Spread the throats out. Three firings at the same throat give one pressure, not three. Aim for at least a factor of two between the lowest and highest mean pressure, or the exponent n cannot be pinned down.

Other configurations

An end-burning test motor, with a bulkhead port for each of several nozzles, is the approach described in Jim Lanier's work. It burns a single flat face at a known area, which makes it neutral by construction, but it needs a long grain inhibited on its outside, and it runs hot for a long time. The short BATES grain above is simpler to cast and to read.

A strand burner measures the rate of a thin strand in a pressurized vessel, without a motor at all. It can be the more precise method, but the rate a strand gives is not always the rate the same propellant burns at in a motor.

See Propellant Characterization for what to do with the data once you have it, and Data Acquisition for instrumenting the test.